Last updated
Like me, I'm sure you've noticed that doctors, nurses and other healthcare professionals often carry an air of calm and control, even when the situation around them is anything but.
It's reassuring, isn't it? You feel you're in good hands.
That confidence isn't learnt from books. It's built over years of experience, and experience doesn't develop in isolation. Somewhere along the way, someone answered a question, talked through a bad shift, or showed them how things really work.
That is where coaching and mentoring come in. The two are often used interchangeably, but they do different jobs. Mentoring usually supports broader, longer-term professional and career development. Coaching focuses on a particular challenge, goal, skill or area of performance.
And the value goes beyond the individual. For healthcare organisations, well-run coaching and mentoring supports workforce development, succession planning, inclusion, retention and the transfer of knowledge between colleagues and generations.
This guide draws on published research, examples from across the NHS, and case studies from healthcare organisations PLD has worked with, from NHS trusts to the Royal College of Midwives.
The essence of this read
Mentoring is broad and long-term. Coaching is focused and short-term. Healthcare adds formal roles that are neither: preceptors, clinical supervisors, and practice supervisors and assessors.
It is moving up the agenda. The 10 Year Health Plan for England promises a personalised career coaching and development plan for every member of NHS staff, and staff survey figures on advocacy and burnout show why support matters.
The research is positive, with conditions. A 2026 review of 74 studies links mentoring in hospitals to confidence, lower stress and burnout, belonging and career choices, but only where access is equal, time is protected and mentors are trained.
The right model depends on the purpose. Eight are in use, from one-to-one to cascade. Reverse mentoring is increasingly used in the NHS.
Care homes need their own approach. "Mentor" usually means an induction buddy or a peer for the registered manager, and shared platforms help small, separate providers.
Schemes work when they are designed to. Clear purpose, thoughtful matching, protected time and firm boundaries matter, and so does measuring what happens after people are matched.
Jump to:
- Mentor, coach, preceptor, supervisor: what is the difference?
- Why coaching and mentoring matter to healthcare organisations
- What mentoring does in healthcare
- Case study: Barts Health NHS Trust - Health Care Horizons
- What coaching does in healthcare
- Mentoring models used in healthcare
- Peer mentoring in healthcare
- How does reverse mentoring in healthcare work?
- Mentoring in care homes and social care
- What makes healthcare mentoring work
- How to tell whether it is working
- Coaching and mentoring work in combination
- Frequently asked questions
- Is coaching or mentoring right for your organisation?
Mentor, coach, preceptor, supervisor: what is the difference?
Healthcare has more names for "someone who helps you develop" than almost any sector, and several are formal roles with their own standards. This is how they sit side by side.
| Role | What it is | Typical length |
|---|---|---|
| Mentor | A longer-term relationship focused on career, confidence and professional identity. The mentor shares experience, and the mentee sets the agenda. | Months to years |
| Coach | Short, structured conversations on a specific goal or skill, using questions and feedback rather than advice. A coach does not need a clinical background. | A set number of sessions |
| Preceptor | Supports a newly registered nurse, midwife or nursing associate through their first year in practice. NHS England's national preceptorship framework sets a core standard of at least six months, with twelve as the gold standard. | Six to twelve months |
| Clinical supervisor | Protected, reflective time with a trained supervisor to talk through practice, decisions and the emotional weight of the work. It is not performance management. | Ongoing |
| Practice supervisor and practice assessor | NMC roles that supervise and assess students on placement. They replaced the old "mentor" title in nursing and midwifery education, which is one reason the word is now so muddled. | Length of the placement |
These are not rungs on one ladder. A newly registered nurse can have a preceptor for the first year, a mentor for career direction and a coach for a specific leadership challenge, all at once, and each does a different job.
The wider difference between coaching and mentoring holds in healthcare as it does anywhere. A mentor is more likely to say: "I've faced something similar. Here is what I learnt." A coach is more likely to ask: "What do you think your options are?" Neither is better. The useful question is not "coaching or mentoring?" but what kind of development this person needs right now. A senior clinician moving into a major leadership role might have a mentor who knows the organisation and, at the same time, a coach to work on leadership behaviour.
Mentoring and clinical supervision also overlap, and should not be confused. Supervision is tied to practice, standards and safe performance. Mentoring is developmental, and the mentor is not responsible for assessing the mentee. That separation is a feature: people say more about uncertainty and ambition when the person supporting them is not also marking them.
Why coaching and mentoring matter to healthcare organisations
Two things have changed the conversation.
The first is policy. The 10 Year Health Plan for England, published in July 2025, commits to ensuring every member of NHS staff has their own personalised career coaching and development plan. However a trust chooses to deliver that, someone has to decide who coaches, who mentors, and how it is tracked.
The second is how people feel. In the 2025 NHS Staff Survey, published in March 2026, the staff advocacy score across NHS organisations in England fell to 58% from 61% the year before, and nearly one in three staff described themselves as burnt out.
Mentoring and coaching will not fix pay or staffing levels. They are a modest intervention, and that is the point: they sit within an organisation's own control, they can be run across a whole trust, and they are aimed at how supported people feel at work. They help in four specific ways.
Keeping knowledge in the building. Much of what experienced staff know is in no manual: how the system really works, who to call, why a service is arranged as it is. NHS England promotes legacy mentoring, where experienced nurses and colleagues in other regulated professions, usually in late career, provide coaching, mentoring and pastoral support. It helps keep people who might otherwise retire, and helps early-career staff "stay and stay well". Barking, Havering and Redbridge NHS Trust reported lower turnover and vacancy rates from its legacy nurse scheme, then extended it to midwives, allied health professionals and healthcare assistants. It is succession planning in a clinical setting.
Getting people through transitions. The hardest moments in a healthcare career are often the changes: from training into practice, into a first management role, into senior leadership, between specialities, back after extended leave, or towards retirement. A mentor helps someone make sense of the change. A coach helps with the goals and decisions that come with the new role.
Growing leaders. Clinical expertise does not automatically create leadership expertise. New leaders inherit difficult conversations, conflicting priorities and decisions that affect people well beyond their own area. Coaching and mentoring give them somewhere safe to work through it. The guide to leadership mentoring looks at this in more depth.
Widening access and belonging. Informal mentoring is rarely shared out equally. Some people naturally find sponsors and advocates, and others never do. A formal scheme opens those relationships to more people, and reverse mentoring gives leaders direct insight into experiences they would not otherwise hear.
What mentoring does in healthcare
Mentoring is crucial for long-term career and personal development in healthcare. This works both ways, as healthcare professionals will utilise multiple types of mentoring and find themselves learning from more experienced staff and in turn passing that knowledge to their more junior colleagues as they supervise them.
Clinical skills are taught. Most of what a mentor adds is not in any curriculum: whether to specialise, how to challenge a senior colleague, how to get through the week after a bad shift, how to progress without leaving the organisation. In practice, mentoring in healthcare tends to give people four things.
Career direction. Someone who has made the decisions you are facing and will say what they wish they had known.
Professional socialisation. The unwritten norms, values and politics of a ward, department or profession.
Emotional support. A confidential space to talk about the pressures of the work with someone who understands them.
Networks. Introductions beyond your own team, specialty or site.
The research is catching up. A 2026 systematic review of 74 studies of mentoring in hospital settings, by Ventimiglia, Setti and Maffoni, found benefits well beyond skills: greater confidence and self-efficacy, lower stress, anxiety and burnout, a stronger sense of belonging, and career choices that favoured demanding specialities and reduced attrition.
It also found that having mentoring available is not enough. Equal access, formal structure, protected time and trained mentors all mattered, as did keeping mentoring separate from assessment. The authors concluded that mentoring supports the growth of junior healthcare professionals, while equitable access, standardisation and further research remain open questions.
Mentoring does not have to begin at registration either. Healthcare Horizons shows it can start before someone enters the workforce at all.
Case study: Barts Health NHS Trust - Health Care Horizons
The Healthcare Horizons programme, supported by Sadiq Khan, aims to introduce East London's youth to NHS careers through direct engagement with 37 secondary schools, offering career events, mentoring, work experiences, and pre-employment training. Focused on local recruitment, it seeks to boost career aspirations, promote Barts Health as an employer, and enhance career guidance, opening up healthcare career opportunities for young Londoners. Read more
PLD's mentoring solution:
Tailored to meet the specific needs of Healthcare Horizons, PLD provided a user-friendly mentoring platform for busy healthcare professionals and 6th form college students. Working closely with the Healthcare Horizons team, PLD provided the mentoring platform at a fixed mentoring software cost and customised a user journey that facilitates easy access and engagement for both mentors and mentees, delivering vital career support to aspiring healthcare students.
"The platform has helped us mentor young people from local schools who are considering a career within the health sector..."
"I really like the fact that we were able to develop a bespoke platform that meets the project needs... The platform is very user-friendly and the reporting functionality is also helpful. Great product."
Barts Health NHS Trust - Health Care Horizons
Results:
75% of registered mentees in the programme have successfully matched with mentors for career advice in their healthcare interest areas, including UCAS application, university interviews, personal statement guidance, and insights into the healthcare sector. Feedback highlights the programme's effectiveness in empowering diverse young people towards healthcare careers. 99% of mentors said they would recommend mentoring to colleagues.
What coaching does in healthcare
Coaching in healthcare is used more for addressing immediate challenges, improving specific competencies, and achieving short-term goals.
Whether or not a coaching software platform is used, coaching is particularly useful for enhancing clinical skills, leadership abilities, and dealing with specific workplace challenges. Coaching tends to be:
Short-Term and Focused: Coaching is generally more short-term and focuses on specific development areas or issues. It's more about enabling the individual to discover answers by themselves.
Skill and Performance Oriented: Coaches work on developing specific skills or behaviours. It's often about improving performance and achieving set goals.
A Structured Approach: Coaching involves a more structured approach with regular sessions and clear objectives.
Questioning and Feedback: Coaches use techniques like active listening, questioning, and feedback to facilitate self-awareness and self-directed learning.
Not Necessarily Provided by Healthcare Experts: Coaches don't necessarily have to be from the healthcare sector. Their expertise is in the coaching process itself.
Where mentoring is broad and long, coaching is narrow and short. It suits a defined moment: a ward manager preparing for a first budget conversation, a consultant stepping into a clinical director role, a team that cannot get handovers right. Because the coach's expertise is the process, coaching works across professions and can work better precisely because the coach brings no assumptions about how things are done on your unit.
Case study: East London NHS Foundation Trust
East London NHS Foundation Trust used PLD for mentoring, coaching and reverse mentoring. Its Organisation Development Business Partner said:
"The platform is very user-friendly for both end users and administrators and has many features and useful reporting dashboards. This allows the organisation to report on the uptake, usage and satisfaction with programmes via evaluation surveys..."
"...It is just great that the platform can be fully-customised upon the organisation's needs - this is both in terms of the set up and visual appearance. It allows for a variety of programmes such as mentoring, coaching and reverse mentoring also."
East London NHS Foundation Trust - Organisation Development Business Partner
Mentoring models used in healthcare
There is no single right shape. These are the mentoring models that appear most often in healthcare, and larger organisations usually run several at once.
One-to-one. The traditional pairing: individual guidance from someone more experienced.
Peer. Colleagues at the same stage supporting each other, reciprocally rather than hierarchically.
Group. One mentor, or a small panel, working with several mentees. Useful when experienced people are scarce.
Reverse. A less experienced colleague, or one whose perspective is under-represented at senior level, mentors a senior one on technology, culture or lived experience.
Cross-disciplinary. Pairs people from different specialisms or professions, so each sees how the other works. A related approach matters for internationally recruited staff, who often need a guide to the culture of the NHS rather than more clinical teaching.
Virtual or e-mentoring. Video and messaging connect people across sites, shifts and countries.
Formal and informal. Informal mentoring happens anyway, but tends to find people who already have the right connections. A formal scheme exists partly to reach everyone else.
Cascade. Senior doctors mentor junior doctors, who in turn mentor medical students, so learning moves through every level.
Peer mentoring and reverse mentoring are of particular importance in healthcare and therefore deserve a little more detail.
Peer mentoring in healthcare
Peer mentoring in healthcare, often called peer to peer mentoring, is a form of mentoring where individuals at similar career levels or with comparable experiences support each other's professional and personal development. Unlike traditional mentoring, where there is a clear mentor-mentee hierarchy based on experience or seniority, peer mentoring is more between equals and is reciprocal. Someone at a similar stage may understand a challenge in a way a much more senior person no longer does, and the lack of hierarchy can make difficult conversations easier.
How does reverse mentoring in healthcare work?
Reverse mentoring in the healthcare sector is a unique and increasingly popular approach that flips the traditional mentoring model. In reverse mentoring, junior staff members or those newer to the field mentor more senior or experienced colleagues.
A good example of this is with the Royal College of Midwives mentoring scheme whose programme also motivated early-career midwives to take on mentoring roles, promoting reverse mentoring and recognising the valuable insights experienced staff can gain from those with less experience.
Reverse mentoring is no longer experimental in the NHS. Nottingham CityCare ran a six-month, Board-led scheme, launched in October 2023, pairing Board members with staff from under-represented groups. Every Board member who took part said it improved their ability as an inclusive leader, and every mentor believed leadership had become more aware of the barriers staff face. NHS England's Chief Pharmacy Office paired 11 junior pharmacists with senior leaders for six months in 2024. All would recommend the programme, and 64% said they understood ethnicity-related barriers at work better. These are small schemes, so read the figures as signals rather than proof.
Case study: Royal College of Midwives
The Royal College of Midwives mentoring scheme, which PLD supported, was set up for Black, Asian and minority ethnic midwives and maternity support workers, and grew out of the Turning the Tide report. In the case study, 76% of mentees who completed their profiles found a suitable mentor.
"There is a dearth of senior leaders of colour in maternity and we hope this mentoring programme will be a catalyst for positive change for these staff and the wider NHS."
Suzanne Tyler, Executive Director, Royal College of Midwives
Case study: Vision Action
Vision Action used PLD for remote mentoring that connected eye health professionals across Ethiopia, Ghana, Sierra Leone, Zambia and the UK, removing geographical barriers through in-platform video.
"It has helped me to improve my daily work with my patients."
Mentee, Vision Action
Mentoring in care homes and social care
In social care, "mentor" usually means one of two people. The first is an experienced care worker who supports a new starter through induction, including the Care Certificate, and shows them how the home really runs. The second is a peer or external mentor for the registered manager, who is often the most senior person on site and may have nobody at the same level to think aloud with.
Both matter for the same reason. Care homes run on small teams, so losing one person is felt quickly, and the manager sets the tone for everyone else.
Delivery is the harder part. In an NHS trust, potential mentors share an employer. In social care, the people who could mentor each other often work for different providers or sit in separate buildings. A shared digital platform solves that more easily than a series of introductions, and the approach has worked elsewhere: London Councils Mentor Connect brings 32 boroughs and the City of London Corporation together on one platform, giving every participant a wider mentor pool than any single council could offer.
What makes healthcare mentoring work
Effective mentorship programmes and mentoring programme design can lead to improved job satisfaction, enhanced skill development, and better patient care outcomes.
Good mentoring relationships can develop informally. A scheme across a whole organisation needs more structure. The aim is not to control every conversation, but to create the conditions in which useful ones can happen. If you are setting one up, these are the decisions that matter most.
Decide what it is for. Keeping newly qualified staff, progressing under-represented groups, building a leadership pipeline and widening access to careers each need different participants, matching criteria and measures. A scheme with no stated purpose cannot be measured. Once the purpose is clear, the mentorship programme structure guide covers how to shape the scheme around it.
Match on what matters. Implement a process for matching mentors and mentees. This could be based on career interests, specialties, or personal preferences. Consider allowing participants to choose their pairs or providing guidance for optimal matching. Development goals, career stage, location and availability all count too, and matching should not mean simply pairing people from the same profession: sometimes similarity helps, and sometimes difference creates more value.
Prepare both sides. Mentors need guidance on listening, questioning, boundaries and resisting the urge to solve every problem, plus a clear sense of when to signpost to occupational health or clinical supervision. Mentees need to take responsibility for the relationship rather than wait for answers.
Protect the time. A scheme can look successful because hundreds of people register while few relationships become active. Protected time, with explicit permission to use it, matters as much as the technology. Shift workers do not have a predictable Tuesday afternoon, so short conversations and video calls fit clinical life far better than a monthly hour in a meeting room.
Case study: NHS Clinical Entrepreneur Programme
The NHS Clinical Entrepreneur Programme, delivered by Anglia Ruskin University and commissioned by NHS England, is described as the world's largest entrepreneurial training programme in healthcare. It replaced manual spreadsheet matching with a platform on a site licence rather than a cost per user.
"Previously we did all our mentor matching manually and as you can imagine this is a very time consuming and laborious process. We wanted a great digital solution that was customisable, scalable and that would help our mentees find their ideal mentor match. PLD provided this and more."
NHS Clinical Entrepreneur Programme
Be clear about boundaries and confidentiality. What is said in mentoring stays there, except where something must be escalated, and the line between mentoring and line management, supervision or performance and fitness-to-practise processes must be explicit from the start.
Keep supporting it. Not every match works. Programme managers need visibility of engagement and a simple way for people to ask for help, raise a concern or be rematched.
Case study: ongoing support
"We could not have asked for a better service from PLD. They were very responsive to our specific platform needs and available to talk to for help and support when needed. Regular check ins from them were also very useful and they have helped to make sure our mentoring platform is successful. After the implementation, regular contact has been maintained, which has led to further refinements and tweaks to improve user experience even further."
Recognise mentors. Protected time, CPD credit or simple public thanks. Mentors who feel valued stay.
Open it up. Staff in less visible roles, on night shifts and at remote sites benefit most from structured access, because they are the least likely to find a mentor informally.
How to tell whether it is working
Registration numbers tell you very little. What matters is what happens after people join, and most of the reasons mentoring programmes fail show up in those numbers early. Schemes tend to stall in the gap between being matched and holding a first conversation, so measure that gap. Useful measures include:
the share of participants who are matched
the share of matches that become active, and first meetings held
relationships still active at three and six months
whether participants complete the intended period
satisfaction with matching and with the experience, from both sides
progress against individual development goals
confidence or capability before and after
moves into new roles or leadership positions
retention and engagement
whether access is equitable across different groups
Let the purpose decide the measures. A scheme built to improve inclusion should not be judged on the same terms as one built for graduate careers. And be cautious about claiming better patient outcomes unless the scheme has been evaluated in a way that supports it: even the 2026 review above calls for further research. Good reporting features make all of this routine instead of a year-end scramble.
Coaching and mentoring work in combination
As you can see from the above, along with other coaching and mentoring examples, both approaches contribute significantly to the professional growth and effectiveness of healthcare personnel, leading to improved patient care and healthcare outcomes. Often, healthcare professionals benefit from a combination of both mentoring and coaching at different stages of their careers.
Most organisations that do this well run coaching and mentoring side by side, each with its own purpose and measures, rather than one scheme with two labels.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between mentoring and preceptorship in healthcare?
Preceptorship is a structured period of support for newly registered nurses, midwives and nursing associates, typically six to twelve months under NHS England's framework, usually with a named preceptor from the same profession. Mentoring is broader and longer. It is not tied to registration, the mentor can sit in a different team, trust or profession, and the mentee sets the agenda. Many people have both.
What is a mentor in a care home?
Usually either an experienced care worker who supports a new starter through induction, or a peer or external mentor who supports the registered manager. Both are covered in the section on mentoring in care homes.
What are the benefits of mentoring in healthcare?
For mentees: confidence, career direction and a sense of belonging. For mentors: practice at leadership and recognition for what they know. For organisations: clearer progression routes, wider access to senior role models and a better view of how supported staff feel. A 2026 systematic review of 74 studies also linked mentoring to lower stress, anxiety and burnout. At Barts Health, 99% of mentors said they would recommend mentoring to colleagues.
Do coaches need a clinical background?
No. A coach's expertise is the process of questioning, feedback and goal-setting. Some organisations prefer coaches who know the setting, and others value an outsider's fresh perspective. Either works if the coach is trained and the purpose is clear.
How do you know whether a healthcare mentoring scheme is working?
Track matches, first meetings, active relationships at three and six months and feedback from both sides, then judge them against the scheme's purpose. The section on how to tell whether it is working lists the measures.
Is coaching or mentoring right for your organisation?
For many organisations the answer will be both. Start with five questions:
Who are you trying to support, and what do they need?
What organisational problem are you trying to solve?
Would shared experience, coaching, peer support or a combination help most?
How will people be matched, and how much structure will the scheme provide?
How will you know whether it is working?
Answer those first. The choice of mentoring model, coaching approach and technology gets much easier afterwards.
There's a free, 3 minute quiz that will help you decide whether a healthcare mentoring programme is the right fit for your organisation.
And, once you've taken the quiz, you can simply book a demo or get in touch if you want to see the mentoring platform in action, first hand.